NEW YORK, NY – As the 2025 MLB season heats up, the perennial discussion around the American League MVP award is gaining significant traction, with New York Yankees captain Aaron Judge firmly entrenched as the leading candidate. However, a compelling dark horse has entered the conversation, adding an intriguing dynamic to what promises to be a captivating race.
According to Yahoo Sports senior MLB analysts Jake Mintz and Jordan Shusterman, hosts of the popular “Baseball Bar-B-Cast” podcast, Judge remains the frontrunner due to his overwhelming offensive superiority across the board. Even a June OPS of .971, which for most players would be a career highlight, was noted by the analysts as “not as good” for him, highlighting the stratospheric standards Judge has set for himself. His consistent power, plate discipline, and all-around offensive game continue to make him a terrifying presence in any lineup.
Yet, a compelling argument is being made for an unexpected challenger: Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh. Dubbed a “delightful” contender by the analysts, Raleigh has commanded high visibility during Mariners games and has put together an impressive power display, smashing 31 home runs before the month of July. His remarkable home run total, especially for a catcher, positions him as a legitimate threat.
While Judge undeniably holds the offensive edge in terms of overall production, Raleigh’s power, crucial role as team captain, and a season described as “amazing” — potentially one of the greatest ever for a catcher — make his case surprisingly strong. Although his defense behind the plate has seen a slight noted decline this year, his continued impact on the Mariners’ success is undeniable.
Ultimately, despite Raleigh’s compelling surge, the “Baseball Bar-B-Cast” analysts project Aaron Judge to clinch the 2025 AL MVP award, with Cal Raleigh securing a well-deserved “delightful 2nd place” finish.
As the season progresses, all eyes will be on these two phenomenal talents. Judge’s consistent brilliance and Raleigh’s unexpected power surge promise to make the 2025 AL MVP race one of the most exciting and closely watched in recent memory.